Open Relationship Guide: How to Set Healthy Boundaries

You've likely encountered the phrase "open relationship" on dating apps, social media, or even popular TV shows. Maybe you swiped right on someone whose Hinge profile mentioned they were in an open relationship, and perhaps you're just curious about what it really means. Open relationships are often misunderstood or idealized in popular culture, but the reality is more nuanced.

An open relationship is a form of ethical non-monogamy (ENM) where partners consensually engage in romantic or sexual connections with others, typically while maintaining one primary partnership. Unlike polyamory, which involves multiple emotionally equal relationships, or swinging, focused primarily on sexual encounters, open relationships include clearly defined emotional and practical boundaries tailored to each couple's comfort and needs.

Establishing clear open relationship rules and boundaries is essential—not to restrict, but to ensure emotional safety, trust, and authentic connection. Recognizing your attachment style can greatly influence how you experience open relationships, affecting everything from managing jealousy to maintaining open communication.

In this guide, we'll cover: Is an Open Relationship Right for You? Common Boundaries in Open Relationships Hierarchical vs. Non-Hierarchical Structures How Attachment Styles Impact Open Relationships Navigating Challenges and Growth Open Relationships in Dating, Marriage, and Long-Term Partnerships Take the Quiz to Understand How You Show Up

Is an Open Relationship Right for You?

Exploring an open relationship isn’t something you jump into lightly. Whether you’re considering this for the first time or revisiting the idea with your partner, the foundation needs to be solid: emotional readiness, clear communication, and mutual understanding.

Start with some key self-reflection:

• Why do people choose open relationships—and why am I drawn to it?
• Is my interest coming from curiosity, personal growth, or unresolved dissatisfaction?
• What emotional patterns (like jealousy or fear of abandonment) tend to show up for me?
• How do I usually respond to emotional stress—do I shut down, seek reassurance, or lash out?
• What kind of conversations do I need to have with my partner before opening up our relationship?

Checklist: Questions to Ask Yourself Before Opening Your Relationship

[] Am I ready to face discomfort without running away from it? [] Can I communicate clearly, even when I feel vulnerable? [] Have I thought about what kind of boundaries would help me feel safe? [] What role does trust play in how I connect to my partner—and how do I maintain it? [] Do I know how to self-soothe and manage my emotions?

How Attachment Styles Can Shape This Decision

Your attachment style isn’t just background noise—it can shape how you approach boundaries, handle uncertainty, and navigate connection in an open relationship.

Attachment Style	In an Open Relationship, You Might...
Secure	Communicate openly, feel grounded in your bond, navigate agreements with trust.
Anxious	Crave reassurance, feel easily triggered by perceived threats, worry about being replaced.
Avoidant	Prefer distance, feel discomfort with vulnerability, struggle to articulate emotional needs.
Fearful-Avoidant	Swing between craving closeness and fearing it, experiencing emotional overwhelm, needs extra clarity.

Understanding your style isn’t about labeling—it’s about awareness. The more you understand your relational patterns, the better you’ll be able to co-create a dynamic that works for both of you.

Common Boundaries in Open Relationships (with Examples)

Boundaries are the framework that helps an open relationship thrive. They provide clarity, foster trust, and ensure that all partners feel respected and understood. Clear boundaries can help prevent misunderstandings and emotional distress, creating a healthier dynamic for everyone involved.

Here are some common types of boundaries to explore and revisit often:

Emotional Boundaries

• No falling in love with other partners
• Disclose if deeper feelings begin to develop

Physical Boundaries

• Practice safer sex with all partners
• Set limits around types of physical intimacy

Time Boundaries

• Reserve specific days for outside dates
• Protect sacred time for the primary relationship

Communication Rules

• Agree on how much to share about other partners
• Decide between full transparency or a “don’t ask, don’t tell” approach

For a deeper dive into setting boundaries across various aspects of your life—including romantic relationships, work, and family—you might find this resource helpful:
How to Set Boundaries in Every Area of Your Life

Top 10 Common Open Relationship Boundaries

Rule	Purpose
Use protection with all partners	Ensures physical safety and health
No overnight stays	Preserves time intimacy with the primary partner
Share all new partners	Builds trust and reduces secrecy
Limit number of partners	Prevents emotional or logistical overwhelm
No friends or coworkers	Keeps social boundaries clear
Discuss feelings if they change	Supports emotional honesty
Avoid certain venues or shared spaces	Prevents overlap and tension
Weekly check-ins	Encourages regular communication
No dating exes	Avoids unresolved emotional baggage
Prioritize important events	Reinforces commitment to the primary relationship

Understanding Open Relationship Structures: Hierarchical vs Non-Hierarchical

Structuring an open relationship means deciding how your various connections function in relation to one another emotionally, practically, and socially.

Some people pursue open relationships to explore emotional or physical intimacy with others, to align their relationship style with personal values around freedom or non-ownership, or to grow through experiences that monogamy may not support. For others, it's a way to de-escalate pressure on a long-term partnership while maintaining connection and care.

Once the decision to explore non-monogamy is made, the next step is to determine how that openness will be structured, because not all open relationships operate the same way. Two of the most common models are hierarchical and non-hierarchical:

Hierarchical

• One relationship is explicitly prioritized; this is often referred to as the "primary" relationship.
• Other connections may be designated secondary or tertiary, with fewer shared commitments or emotional investments.
• This model can offer emotional clarity and logistical stability.

Non-Hierarchical

• All partners are treated with equal priority in terms of emotional importance and autonomy.
• There are no official "primary" or "secondary" roles—just negotiated, evolving connections.
• This approach can feel more inclusive and liberating, but often requires a high level of emotional maturity, communication, and conflict resolution skills.

There’s no one-size-fits-all model. The best structure for your open relationship depends on your needs, values, life stage, and of course, your attachment style. Here’s how different attachment styles might navigate different models:

Secure Attachment – Non-Hierarchical Example
Amira feels confident in her ability to set boundaries and express emotions. She's dating two people openly and equally, and both relationships feel nourishing. She doesn't need to assign priority because emotional safety is maintained through regular communication.

Anxious Attachment – Hierarchical Example
David struggles with jealousy and often seeks reassurance. He feels safer having a clear primary partner who he can turn to for emotional grounding, while still having room to explore other connections with transparent agreements.

Avoidant Attachment – Non-Hierarchical Example
Tasha values autonomy and dislikes feeling constrained. She maintains multiple non-hierarchical connections and prefers to keep emotional intimacy light. Her partners appreciate the independence, but conflicts might arise when emotional needs aren’t discussed explicitly.

Fearful-Avoidant – Hierarchical with Boundaries Example
Leo wants a deep connection but also feels easily overwhelmed. His open relationship includes one designated primary partner who helps him feel stable, while external relationships are limited in scope to manage emotional overload. Clear agreements and check-ins help him stay present.

How Attachment Styles Impact Open Relationships

Attachment styles don’t disappear when a relationship opens up. In fact, they often become more pronounced. Non-monogamy can bring up a wide range of emotional triggers, making it even more important to recognize and understand your attachment tendencies. Each style comes with its own vulnerabilities, needs, and growth opportunities in an open dynamic.

Anxious Attachment in Open Relationships

People with anxious attachment often fear abandonment and seek frequent reassurance. In an open relationship, these fears may intensify, especially if they feel their partner is becoming emotionally invested in someone else.

Challenges:

• Jealousy may be more intense and persistent.
• They might fear being replaced or not being "enough."
• Constantly comparing themselves to other partners.

Supportive Practices:

• Create emotional rituals (e.g., goodnight calls, regular affirmation).
• Use shared calendars or agreements to provide predictability.
• Maintain transparency and offer space for processing.

Avoidant Attachment in Open Relationships

Avoidantly attached individuals may appreciate the independence that open relationships offer, but they may also use multiple partners as a way to avoid deeper emotional intimacy.

Challenges:

• May avoid tough emotional conversations.
• Might keep connections shallow to feel in control.
• Tendency to disengage when others seek closeness.

Supportive Practices:

• Practice sharing vulnerable feelings even in small ways.
• Clarify emotional needs rather than retreating.
• Structure check-ins that encourage emotional presence without pressure.

Fearful-Avoidant Attachment in Open Relationships

Fearful-avoidant individuals often experience inner conflict between wanting closeness and fearing it. Open relationships can intensify this ambivalence.

Challenges:

• Difficulty trusting partners.
• Can swing between clinginess and withdrawal.
• Emotional overwhelm.
• Can see boundaries as punitive, not protective.

Supportive Practices:

• Keep agreements clear and consistent.
• Introduce openness gradually with boundaries around scope and pacing.
• Encourage therapy or journaling to sort through emotional contradictions.

Moving Toward Secure Attachment

Security isn’t about never feeling triggered—it’s about having the tools and support to navigate those moments with grace. Open relationships can be an opportunity to heal old wounds and practice secure behaviors:

Pathways to Security:

• Co-create safety with your partner through consistency and empathy.
• Cultivate emotional literacy. Name feelings, needs, and fears.
• Learn to self-regulate without relying solely on a partner.

Remember: Open relationships don’t fix attachment wounds—but they can bring them into the light. With awareness, compassion, and intentional communication, they can also become a space for profound personal and relational growth.

Navigating Challenges and Growth

Even the most aligned couples experience tension, especially in open dynamics, where layers of communication and emotion can intensify insecurities. Growth in these moments isn’t just expected; it’s necessary for the relationship to thrive. Here’s how to meet those challenges effectively:

Jealousy vs. Envy

It’s common to feel something when your partner connects with someone else—but what exactly are you feeling?

• Jealousy often involves fear of losing something we already have.
• Envy can arise from desiring something someone else has.

Understanding the root of the emotion helps you respond more thoughtfully. Use it as an entry point for deeper reflection:

• What need is going unmet?
• What story am I telling myself?
• What am I afraid of?

When Boundaries Get Crossed

Broken agreements don’t always mean betrayal, but they do signal a need for recalibration. When a boundary is crossed:

• Acknowledge it together, without deflection or blame.
• Ask: Was it unclear? Was it agreed on? Was it realistic?
• Repair through accountability: What will rebuild trust moving forward?

Mistakes vs. Disrespect

Boundary slips are part of being human—especially in new or evolving dynamics. Maybe someone misunderstood an agreement, or made a choice from a place of fear or insecurity. These moments are repairable with communication and care.

But patterns matter. If someone constantly violates boundaries after conversations, dismisses your feelings, or avoids accountability, that’s not a slip—it’s a signal. Rebuilding trust requires both partners to be engaged in the repair process and committed to respecting shared agreements.

Communication Breakdowns

You won’t always say the perfect thing. But the goal isn’t perfection—it’s connection.

• Use a structure like "I feel, I need, I propose" to express concerns.
• Listen to understand, not just to respond.
• Validate the emotion, even if you don’t agree with the interpretation.

When It’s Time to Reassess

Open relationships are not static—they’re evolving systems. Periodic check-ins create space to realign.

• Revisit agreements every few months.
• Ask: What’s working? What feels strained? Are our goals still aligned?
• Be open to redefining the structure if needs have changed.

Open Relationships in Dating, Marriage, and Long-Term Partnerships

How an open relationship functions often depends on the container it lives within. Here’s how structure and intention shift across contexts:

Relationship Type	Considerations
Open Dating	Offers greater freedom and flexibility, but can lack clarity around exclusivity or emotional boundaries. Best suited to those exploring identity, values, or new relationship styles.
Open Marriage	Involves long-term commitment, often with shared finances or parenting. Requires high levels of transparency and aligned values, especially when navigating legal or social expectations.
Long-Term Partnerships	With or without legal marriage, these partnerships carry depth and shared history. Openness must evolve as life circumstances do—careers, children, or illness may shift needs and agreements.

The foundation is the same across all formats: mutual respect, emotional presence, and a shared commitment to growth—even when the path isn’t linear.

Commitment, clarity, and emotional presence are key regardless of the relationship.

Take the Quiz to Understand How You Show Up in Open Relationships

Curious how your emotional patterns shape the way you love—and how they might show up in an open relationship? Your attachment style can influence everything from how you set boundaries, to how you manage jealousy, to how you communicate with multiple partners.

Take the Attachment Style Quiz to find out what your core relationship blueprint looks like.

Explore courses like How to Repair Any Relationship to strengthen your tools for repair and connection.

Join the 14-Day Relationship Challenge if you're looking to build better habits and create more secure dynamics.

Open relationships aren’t for everyone—but for some, they offer a unique space for healing, freedom, and emotional growth. Wherever you land, understanding yourself is the best place to start.

Share this Article