Affect Theory: How We Understand Emotions in Relationships

Throughout my years of working with people struggling to navigate their emotional lives, I’ve realized something powerful: our relationship reactions are biologically wired responses.

Emotions are not just a "random response," or a "choice" someone makes because they lack self-control; they're signals that guide how we connect, withdraw, and protect ourselves.

Once you understand these underlying patterns, you can start to shift them, creating healthier, more consistent connections with the people who matter most.

Psychologist Silvan Tomkins revealed that beneath our conscious emotions lie nine core affects, or pre-programmed biological responses that fire before we even know what we're feeling. This is called affect theory.

If you're searching for what affect theory means, you're probably sensing there's something deeper than just "emotions" driving your reactions.

You're right. And we'll dive into that in this article.

Did you know that your attachment style fundamentally changes how you experience these affects?

While most articles explain affect theory through politics or philosophy, I'll show you:

• How it directly explains your relationship patterns
• Why some people run "hot and cold"
• Why others seem emotionally unavailable
• How understanding affects can transform your ability to connect.

What is Affect Theory?

Affect theory is the study of pre-conscious, biological responses that occur before we consciously experience emotions.

Developed by psychologist Silvan Tomkins in his groundbreaking work "Affect Imagery Consciousness" (1962), this theory reveals we're born with nine innate affects, or hard-wired responses that are processed before our thinking brain engages.

There are three types of "Affects":

• The Positive Affects
• The Neutral Affects
• The Negative Affects

Think of affects as your body's instant reaction system. When your partner walks in with a certain expression, your body responds before you consciously think, "they're upset."

That immediate tightening in your chest, the slight lean backward: that's affect in action. It's what Tomkins called the "biological portion of emotion."

The theory gained mainstream attention in 1995 when Eve Kosofsky Sedgwick and Adam Frank published “Shame in the Cybernetic Fold”, alongside Brian Massumi's "The Autonomy of Affect.” This "affective turn" transformed how we understand human experience—suddenly, researchers realized much of what drives behavior happens before conscious thought.

Affects are the foundation of how we connect or disconnect in relationships.

When someone with an Anxious-Preoccupied attachment style experiences the fear-terror affect (we'll get into this later,) their body amplifies it into overwhelming abandonment anxiety. When someone with an Avoidant style feels the same affect, they suppress it so quickly that they might not even register it. Same affect, completely different experiences.

Affects vs. Emotions vs. Feelings: The Critical Distinction

Understanding the difference between affects, feelings, and emotions explains why you and your partner can experience the same event so differently.

Affects are your body's immediate, pre-conscious responses. They're biological, universal, and you can't control their initial firing. When someone slams a door, everyone experiences the surprise-startle affect instantly.

Feelings occur when you become conscious of the affect, and your personal history gives it meaning. Your experience determines interpretation. If you grew up in a volatile household, that door slam might feel like "danger." If you grew up in a secure household, it's just "someone's having a bad day."

Emotions are the social display of feelings. They're what you show the world after everything's processed. This is where attachment styles really diverge. The anxiously attached person might display panic, seeking reassurance. The avoidant shows withdrawal and coldness, having already suppressed the feeling.

Affect theory could be the key to understanding every confusing interaction in your relationship. Here are some practical examples:

Event	Affect (0.5 sec)	Feeling (3 sec)	Emotion (10 sec)
Partner doesn't text back	Distress (universal)	Anxious Preoccupied: "They're leaving me." Dismissive Avoidant: "Good, space." Fearful Avoidant: “Something’s wrong with me.” Securely Attached: "They're busy."	Anxious Preoccupied: Multiple texts.  Avoidant Dismissive: No acknowledgment. Fearful Avoidant: Texts them and turns their phone on "Do Not Disturb." Securely Attached: Waits calmly.
Partner expresses affection	Enjoyment-Joy	Anxious Preoccupied: "Finally, they really care!" Dismissive Avoidant: "Too close, backing off." Fearful Avoidant: "This seems dangerous." Securely Attached: "This feels nice."	Anxious Preoccupied: Clings or mirrors affection excessively. Dismissive Avoidant: Pulls away subtly. Fearful Avoidant: Tests to see if it's genuine. Securely Attached: Responds warmly and reciprocates naturally.
Partner disagrees on something	Anger-Rage	Anxious Preoccupied: "They’re upset with me!" Dismissive Avoidant: "They’re being unreasonable, I’ll disengage." Fearful Avoidant: "This feels dangerous. I'm going to leave them first so I don't get left." Securely Attached: "Okay, we have different views."	Anxious Preoccupied: Arguments escalate quickly. Dismissive Avoidant: Withdraws, avoids conflict. Fearful Avoidant: Ends things out of fear. Securely Attached: Negotiates and listens.

Tomkins' Nine Core Affects System

Tomkins identified nine innate affects every human is born with—they're our "primary motivational system." Understanding these revolutionizes how you see your reactions and your partner's behavior.

The Positive Affects

• Interest–Excitement: This affect makes you lean in, eyes widen, and attention sharpens. In relationships, it naturally draws you toward your partner, creating curiosity and engagement. For those with avoidant attachment, leaning in can feel risky or unsafe, so this affect is often suppressed, creating distance even when desire for closeness exists.
• Enjoyment–Joy: The affect of connection, often expressed through smiling, laughter, or shared fun. For Fearful Avoidants, experiencing joy can trigger immediate anxiety—“When will this end?”—which contributes to the familiar hot-and-cold pattern in relationships.

The Neutral Affect

• Surprise–Startle: A reset affect that interrupts ongoing emotions and grabs attention. What happens next depends on attachment style: anxiously attached people may convert surprise into fear or worry, while Dismissive Avoidants often respond by shutting down completely, avoiding engagement.

The Negative Affects

• Distress–Anguish: The crying or upset response signaling that something is wrong. People with Secure Attachment seek comfort and support when this arises. Avoidant individuals, having learned early that showing distress invites criticism or rejection, often suppress it automatically, leaving emotions unexpressed.
• Anger–Rage: Ranging from mild irritation to full-blown fury, anger often covers underlying distress or fear. In relationships, when a partner snaps or loses patience, it’s not about you personally, it’s a reflection of their own vulnerability and discomfort with emotions.
• Fear–Terror: Triggers the fight, flight, or freeze response. Anxiously attached individuals may live in near-constant alert for signs of abandonment, while avoidants experience fear of engulfment or loss of independence, prompting withdrawal or distancing behaviors.
• Shame–Humiliation: One of the most influential affects in relationships. Shame interrupts positive emotions, abruptly turning interest or joy into feelings of wrongness or inadequacy. Early attachment wounds can create chronic shame activation, shaping adult relational patterns.
• Disgust and Dismissal (“Dissmell”): Both are rejection-based affects. Disgust pushes away what feels toxic or unsafe, while dissmell—Tomkins’ term—represents withdrawal from offense, the emotional core behind contempt or cold distance in interactions.

What makes this revolutionary for relationships? These affects are universal, but your attachment style determines their intensity, duration, and what happens next.

How Affect Theory Explains Your Relationship Patterns

Every confusing relationship dynamic suddenly makes sense through affect theory. That partner who runs hot and cold? They're not playing games, they're experiencing rapid affect dysregulation. When enjoyment-joy becomes too intense, their Fearful Avoidant system reads it as danger, triggering shame or fear that makes them pull away.

Affective Resonance: Why You "Catch" Emotions

Tomkins discovered we automatically mirror the affects we see in others. It happens in milliseconds. When your partner radiates anger, your body produces the same affect before you even process what's happening.

But here's the key: your attachment style determines how quickly you resonate and what you do with it. Research shows anxiously attached individuals have an increased affective evaluation—they catch and amplify their partner's affects. If their partner shows mild distress, they experience anguish.

Avoidantly attached individuals experience a decrease in affective evaluation. They feel the initial contagion but suppress it. They're not cold; they're protecting themselves from affect overwhelm.

Script Theory

We don't just experience individual affects, either. We create behavioral scripts around affect sequences. These scripts, formed in childhood, become autopilot in adult relationships.

A child reaching for connection (interest-excitement) who consistently meets rejection develops the script: "Interest leads to shame." As adults, the moment they feel interest in their partner, shame automatically triggers, making them pull back.

I've identified four primary affect scripts:

• Anxious Preoccupied Script: "Any negative affect means abandonment."
• Dismissive Avoidant Script: "Positive affects are dangerous."
• Fearful Avoidant Script: "All affects are unstable."
• Securely Attached Script: "Affects are information, not emergencies."

You can't change your initial affects, they're hardwired, but you can absolutely change the scripts that follow.

What’s Your Attachment Style?
Take our quick 5-minute Attachment Style quiz to discover which style is impacting your relationships!

The Attachment-Affect Connection

This is where my work builds on traditional affect theory. In conjunction with Tomkins' research, attachment styles help explain how different people process the nine core affects, highlighting patterns that influence relationships and emotional responses.

Your attachment style doesn't change which affects you have—everyone has all nine. It determines:

• Activation Threshold: How easily each triggers
• Amplification: How much it magnifies
• Duration: How long it persists
• Recovery: Return to baseline speed

Take the fear-terror affect in relationships for each attachment style:

Anxious Preoccupied Attachment:

• Hair-trigger activation (silence = danger)
• Significant amplification (concern → panic)
• Lasts hours to days
• Only recovers with reassurance

Fearful & Dismissive Avoidant:

• High threshold (only extremes register)
• Instant suppression (substantial dampening)
• Lasts seconds if at all
• "Recovery" through denial

Secure Attachment:

• Appropriate threshold and response
• Proportional amplification
• Situationally appropriate duration
• Natural recovery

Core Wounds as Chronic Affect Activation

Here's what no one else is discussing: attachment wounds aren't just psychological—they're chronic affect dysregulation. The "I'm not enough" wound of anxious attachment? That's chronic shame-humiliation coupled with distress-anguish, literally stuck in a biological shame response.

You can't think your way out of an affect problem; you have to regulate your way out. This is why body-based approaches may be more effective than talk therapy alone for deep affect dysregulation. You need interventions addressing the dysregulation directly.

Recognizing Affect Activation

Most people don't realize when they're in affect activation—they just think they're "upset." But recognizing it in real-time transforms your patterns. Here are the key signs:

Immediate Physical (0-2 seconds):

• Face temperature change (hot = anger/shame, cold = fear)
• Breathing disruption (holding or hyperventilating)
• Specific muscle tension (jaw = anger, shoulders = fear)
• Heart rate spike (10-30 beats per minute)

Behavioral Changes (2-5 seconds):

• Eye movement shifts (locking on or darting away)
• Body positioning (leaning in or pulling back)
• Voice changes mid-sentence
• Unconscious proximity adjustments

Cognitive Signs (5-10 seconds):

• Racing thoughts or mental blankness
• Time perception warping
• Tunnel vision on the trigger
• Instant story creation based on attachment style

Each attachment style has a signature pattern:

• Anxious Preoccupied: Shows all signs dramatically
• Dismissive Avoidant: Brief signs, then suppression
• Fearful Avoidant: Rapid alternation between showing and hiding
• Securely Attached: Appropriate signs without overwhelm

The key? Catch activation in the first 2 seconds—that's your intervention window.

Practical Scripts for Affect Communication

These scripts bypass the stories your attachment style creates and address what's actually happening:

• Recognition (For Yourself): "I'm experiencing [affect] right now. My body is [sensation]. My attachment wants to [typical response], but I can choose differently."
• Partner Communication: "I'm in [affect] activation. This isn't about you. It's my nervous system responding to [trigger]. I need [specific support]."

Attachment-Specific Examples:

• Anxious: "I'm in distress because you haven't texted. I know you're busy, but can you send a quick emoji so my nervous system calms?"
• Dismissive Avoidant:"I'm feeling joy with you, and it's triggering some fear. I want to stay present, but might need a 5-minute break. This means I care."
• Fearful Avoidant:"I'm cycling between excitement and shame. Part of me wants closeness, part wants to run. Can we go slow?"

These scripts work because they name biological reality without blame, request specific support, and maintain connection during difficulty.

Conclusion

Understanding affect theory transforms how you experience emotions and relationships. You now know that beneath every feeling lies one of nine core affects—biological responses firing before conscious thought—and your attachment style fundamentally shapes how you process them.

You're not broken for having intense reactions or seeming disconnected. You're experiencing the same affects as everyone else, just filtered through different attachment patterns. That hot and cold partner isn't manipulating—they're struggling with affect dysregulation. Your anxiety isn't weakness, it's amplified affects. Their distance isn't a lack of love, it's protection.

You can't stop affects from firing, but you can change what happens in those crucial seconds after. With practice in recognizing activation and implementing the scripts, you can transform your patterns and earn secure attachment. Start today: notice your next affect activation. Don't try to change it. Just notice. Recognition is the first step to regulation, and regulation is the path to secure, lasting love.

Ready to transform your attachment style and improve how you express yourself in relationships? Join thousands who’ve discovered that understanding affect theory offers life-changing, practical tools to communicate your needs effectively.

Need More Guidance?
Explore our full Expressing Your Needs: Scripts for Effective Communication course to practice using these scripts in real time.

Share this Article